Magic Accuracy And Enfeebling Ninjutsu

Just a question looking at the Koga sash Magic Acc yet ninjutsu is not magic? Int affects ninjutsu spells and is used in calculations for magic acc so I would think magic acc does affect ninjutsu.

Ninjutsu is affected by magic acc.

How are either of those not magic? They are under the magic menu.

Fair enough, just curious.

I think what he meant by that is that the game, solely based on lore, doesn't classify either as "magic". Singing is something of a psychological benefit/detriment, and ninjutsu is the manipulation of tools to create a reaction. These two types also aren't subject to arcane aggression.

But like Sekundes said, they are in the "magic" menu in the game... so, I would say that clearly the game recognizes them as "magic."

If you gotta fight something or use something to learn it, its magic!

Right, but what is the context here? We could go with your "lore." And that is fine, but for all realistic purposes in this game; or more specifically, Magic Accuracy in this game (given the OP), shouldn't we go with a thumbs up on it being magic?

I understand the idea of semantics... but when the context is FFXI and, furthermore, something even more specific, then I am not even sure what is meant by semantics... Yes, they are magic.

Basic functions of gameplay =/= lore

One tosses the two into the magic category, one doesn't. Don't know how to be more clear.

I am not arguing that... I see your point, and no need to argue against it. Just saying that the question was about Magic Accuracy. The game is very clear in how it sees that, that is all.

pfft! wsnms! those aren't magic!