Weapons For PUP

Kenkonken > Verethragna > STR/ATK Trial H2H > Brawny, Stringing Pummel is an awesome WS as well, but if you don't have it Shijin Spiral works. There are 'new' hand to hand out there but I don't know how good they are for PUP yet.

Brawny and shijin will be more consistent but in abyssea and or if you have enough +crit rate Victory smite will win all and all a toss up in my book depending on gear can't go wrong with brawny the bas e damage and stats are sweet. The new h2h will beat em both tho base damage 42+ yes please.....

You forgot to mention the Blutkrallen/Blutklauen (NQ/HQ) h2h that has the def down effect, which are going to be on par, if not better than, Verethragna for Stringing Pummel and Shijin Spiral. Of course there are the new h2h with the DMG: 59, along with additional stats, and the Girru from Legion, which come with STR+10 DEX+10 as well, which should also beat the STR/ATT h2h.

With the new change to attack and defense the blutkrallen family is HAWTTTTTTTTTTTT defense down is the ***now a days no doubt about it. Oh yeah D 42 doesnt suck....