Ragnarok.Jessikah said:
» it's definitely no fault of the Xbox. I know the common understanding is that the West "evolved", leaving the East in the dust. But holy cow, have you gone back and looked at the crap they were putting out?
With the rise of the Xbox came the rise of western game development marketing.
In the market of video games, RPGs, Japanese or Western, both compete with all other game genres for the dollah dollah bills $$$.
It was because of the increased pressure from the surging Western markets, and the way they advertised and took control of video game TV as well.
Within gaming's own sphere, JRPG enthusiasts were pushed to the fringe by all the newcomers (and had slowly been getting pushed that way for years with the late 90s being a heyday that quickly fell away), and any Xbox exclusive JRPGs were oddities / said to be hard to come by (lookin' at you, Tales of Vesperia).
Couple that with the fact that almost every game that came out on the Xbox also came out on PC, and PC gamers were starting to eat well/take from consoles, and transition lifelong console gamers towards PCs ( MMOs also had a hand in this, and this is important because there's an entire subsect of PC gamers who have always looked down on JRPGs due to viewing PC RPGs as better/true).
Then you take into account that the leading creative talents like Hironobu Sakaguchi weren't part of the biggest name brand in JRPGs, leading to weakness in those creative divisions.
Even in positive reviews for turn based RPGs, you read things like, "Even though they're making use of a dated genre..." or "Even though this spectacular game is for a niche market..."
It wasn't Xbox by itself. Xbox was just the launchpad to change public opinion via shifting the market demographic as well as through mass media presence/lack thereof. It's less that the, "West Evolved" and more that, "The West Became Exclusionary/Had an excuse to let that monster out of its cage."
You pair that all up with Eastern corpos not knowing what sells well/wanting to emulate other crap, and the greats of old either getting out of the game or run into creative dead ends, and then you get a wonderful thing where the negative things media say about JRPG = True to the fresh eyes of all those new gamers.