I am working to optimize tp gain in my melee set. Is the melee tp set in the guide current and does it also apply when main handing fettering and off handing degan for savage spam with 1k tp totm gun? What do most people use on ambuscade melee cape? I took stp but I have seen da and dw (assuming acc/att/dex). Last is herc w/ 4ta better than nq adhemar for hand slot? It doesn't seem worth the stp loss. I'm subbing nin in most cases and currently only cping on apex and joining Leviathan shouts. Thanks for any info.
I was playing with spreadsheet earlier to answer your question and found that a high number sam roll favors more multi attack in gears, and low number sam roll(Something like No.7 no job bonus) favors more stp.
So DA ambuscade cap could beat stp at high sam roll and vice versa, and herc 4 ta augment(6 TA total) could beat adhemar nq hands at high sam roll as well.
If I were you I'd just download Chiaia's newest spreadsheet and see it yourself.
personally I roll with stp melee back because I also single wield with /WAR for last stand build, and /WAR favors stp back with DA job trait and mainhand OAT weapon. stp +10 could also be used for QD stp set(useful for savage build since your QD aren't going to do any dmg anyways) and occult acument set. So it's 1 backpiece that can be used in 3 sets.
I may make a dw back for low haste situations though. DW back is also useful if you have a strong augmented herc body with TA and QA, or if you tp in thaumas for suicide reasons ._.;
I think your tp set acc is a little bit too high from my experience, and your DW isn't capped without DNC in pt as there are zero DW piece in your set.
If your group roll with BRDs from my experience usually a set like this is enough to cap melee acc on most things:
ItemSet 340332
Suppa+ petrov combo or cessance+ haverton are pretty much sidegrade, one may be winning another depending on situation but the difference is small, so just pick one that you like. Since your Dampening is max I'd just use that over adhemar nq. Carmine HQ feet may beat herc at low sam roll situations, but a strong herc feet is usually better with higher acc. I would avoid losing windbuffet +1 in waist, it's too good.
Edit: Fixed sam roll number.....