A party set up with RUN COR GEO BARD WHM with a WAR will do much more dmg than a party with a sam/drk/mnk/drg instead. Warcry is just that strong.It is no longer which DPS does the most damage, it is more of which dps brings more to the table other than dmg. OF all the DPS, war brings the most to the party. IMO sam actually brings the least overall to a party. DRG has the pet, drk has magic and mnk has mantra/SB. In situations where you can solo SC. I tend to give sam the edge, war is good at it too though with better 3 and 4 steps. War can close with their best WS twice in a row for light light, and doesnt suffer from the curse of fudo. A DPS party with a war is better than a party without a war. Not to mention how well Upheaval can SC with cor/sam/drk/rune/everyone. War also has better utility weaponskills than any other job. Weapon/armor/shield/full break.
Basically any job that uses a WS that scales with TP wont do it's best damage unless they are in a party with a WAR. Same for crit WS. Should see what sam can do with shining one if paired with a war lol. So basically all of the DD want to party with a war.
Also, this is a super hot take, but I think people way over value MS/BR
I find warcry overall to be better than MS/BR
Zerging helms on war is actually pretty easy (and mnk/sam/drg). Dont need a tank for most of the helms, dont need MS for most of them either. I would say war is handily the best DPS for helms.
If you could only have 1 of either WAR or SAM
If you saying this as which job you would prefer in a DPS part, then war wins easily because it buffs the party.
If you are referring to which one you enjoy playing more? idk both are fun. up to you.
Which one is easier to gear? Between sam//drk/war I would call it a wash. War doesnt really want a rem weapon, but war is good with a LOT of weapons. You end up getting a lot of stuff. Chango is
genreally the best weapon on war, but not always. Spiral hell inside of escha during warcry is doing strange things. Like more dmg than it mathematically should. Shining one can do strange things too in alliance parties. Resolution will actually beat upheaval by a lot during MS etc. Raetic reso with or without MS inside of escha is pretty nuts.
Is a 99,999 Radiance really better than a 99,999 light?
This is a prime example of looking at just the big number. Doji might be tied with masa on the end of the SC, but doji wins on every other fusion/grav etc.
Also doji has jinpu craziness.
If you want a conversation on which DPS and why, then go to the actual thread for it
https://www.ffxiah.com/forum/topic/54386/what-heavy-dd-would-you-pick-and-why
Been like 3 threads asking about it in the last few months.