Why Does BG Wiki Have Admin-protected Slurs?

The "Meme" category on BG wiki contains a lot of admin-protected (uneditable) pages:
https://www.bg-wiki.com/ffxi/Category:Meme

Among these are "Guild" and, of course, the FFXI meme that everyone totally knows, "Mentally Deficient". Both of which have the r-slur on them:
https://www.bg-wiki.com/ffxi/Guild
https://www.bg-wiki.com/ffxi/Mentally_Deficient

I suggested removing the entirety of the Meme category over on the suggestions page, and got the nebulous reply that
"BG mods/admins discussed Meme pages and agreed they prefer them to stay."
entirely via the edit history on said pages:


So the slurs get to stay too! Apparently keeping all the meme pages means we also have to keep the slurs! We must preserve the important classic FFXI culture of, checks notes:

2017. This page was created in twenty *** SEVENTEEN. The same classic FFXI culture of the year where Omen was the hot new endgame content.

edit: Oh. My bad. The "Mentally Deficient" page is obviously not from 2017.

It's from Twenty God Damn Twenty Three.

...Are you *** KIDDING ME?!

As I posted over there on the Suggestions page, I will not be editing the BG Wiki any further until, at minimum, those two slurs are removed - plus any others I don't know about, I'm not going to say there aren't more.

"BG mods/admins": What exactly are you thinking? You clearly discussed this, so by all means, please do air out the results of your discussion publicly.

Signed, StaplerGuy on the wiki, Joespreadsheet on Phoenix, formerly Lightninghelix on Asura. I'm a bad poster and I'm here to make it everyone's problem until the slurs are gone.

oh also there's some other stuff that isn't technically a slur but sure is cringe as *** in this day and age:
https://www.bg-wiki.com/ffxi/The_History_of_Final_Fantasy_XI/2005


obviously I'm not searching text in images but uhhhhhh yeah haha "funny" yeah haha is it 2006

Honestly, it feels absolutely crazy for the admins to act like the painfully unfunny meme pages are somehow load-bearing and in need of protection. Thought the wiki was meant to be an informative resource for the game. dumb as hell

Remembering who the community was is informative.

Pieces of ***then and now, erasing the evidence doesn't change history.

What does keeping a slur tell us, other than that the admins were - oops, still are! same admins! - slur-users in 2017 and 2023?

Like, this is the argument in favor of keeping Confederate statues. Trust me, I ain't gonna forget the general tone of the ***people said in 2006 with or without some "object lessons" from 2017 or 2023.

This whole thread is hard-R HELP I AM TRAPPED IN 2006 PLEASE SEND A TIME MACHINE.

I wish my life was so good that a buried page from 2023 was the worst problem in my life.

I actually admire Spicy's ability to ragebait from beyond the FFXIAH grave.

i think it just proves ppl became so sensitive since these pages were created.

it's just history piece don't overthink it, a lot of media/content from that era would be considered inappropriate nowadays.

History piece? 2023 is history now?

Absolutely correct. I will not be changing my viewpoint of "slurs are bad".

The admins clearly agree they are problematic or they wouldn't have protected them. It's extremely embarrassing.

The pages should absolutely be removed. Claiming they are part of the games history is laughable given their age, and I don't think a history of when slurs were considered cool is worth enshrining on a game wiki.

Streisand effect

Pissing in the wind mate.

BG Wiki blocks email providers they don't like. No way this is changing.

Come at me bro, what.

Oh, absolutely. If they'd just let those two go I wouldn't care even slightly about keeping the rest of the "Meme" category. But now I'm being loud and we're finding out exactly how many people are hellbent on "it's just words".

Would you be so kind as to remove the vulgarities and blaspheming from your posts? Specifically the f-word and G-D cursing. I find both offensive, and since words are not just words, I hope you will agree they have no place on these forums.

That was my favorite ban gif profile picture forever.

For nostalgia:

r*tard isn't a slur. It's a medical term that was coopted and used hyperbolically because it turns out, people of medium intelligence really don't like dealing with people of low intelligence. Same goes for mentally deficient. Legitimate term used hyperbolically(honestly, probably not even hyperbolic in all cases).

Every time you cancel a term that indicates someone is less intelligent than the average, a new one has to be made. It's a necessary concept.

...old vermillion/black cloak were massively better icons, btw.

if it's not a slur why didn't you say it :)

Seriously, I know about the euphemism treadmill. But even you who are arguing it's a slur won't say it because you feel like it shouldn't be said

edit: oh wow I gave Thorny too much credit there huh

There is used to be a filter that changes it to HELP I AM TRAPPED IN 2006 PLEASE SEND A TIME MACHINE.

I didn't realize the filter had finally been lifted and wanted to convey the word I was referring to rather than confusing the reader.

hey are you the Hya who edited the wiki with the statement about how mods/admins agreed to keep this stuff

Oh it's still in effect, please see my post above.

Great idea, let me just make an account with my anonymised email provider..

Oh waaaaaaaaaait........


(/runs)